Posted by: Moose in England, Rugby, tags: Bbc, Charlie Hodgson, England Players, England Team, Forward Pass, Linesman, Referee, Rules Of Rugby Union, Second Half, Second Try
Yes, that was the opening line in the BBC’s report of England’s match against the All Blacks.
Personally speaking I switched off when New Zealand scored their two tries in the opening 10 minutes of the second half. The first try (in the second half) was scored after a forward pass. If someone passes the ball a yard before the 22 yard line and the receiver takes that ball two yards in front of said line, then chances are it was forward. The linesman was in direct line the referee was there but yet no not one person questioned the try, not even the commentators.
The second try was a result of an England fumble but seconds previous, the ball was knocked forward, by a New Zealander, thanks to a Charlie Hodgson tackle. While the England players stopped, expecting the referee to call a scrum in their favour, the All Blacks scored.
So the final score of 37-20 with 14 points removed makes it 23-20 - hardly put to the sword for a young inexperienced England team.
The English pack, I thought, were amazing and outshone the New Zealand pack (although perhaps only just) but I freely admit that the better team on the day won, but put to the sword - hardly.
I now find the rules of Rugby Union so complicated and the ability of so many people to have different interpretations of these rules that the game now holds little interest for me.
Ask your Rugby mates to explain certain decisions during a match and they will fail to do this or at best will have a completely different view to the next bloke. Once the Rugby Union fraternity (players, coaches, officials and commentators) admit they don’t know the rules we will have a chance to clean up the game for everyone but I am afraid to admit the obvious would be just too embarrassing.
No Comments »
Well, I did say hopefully. But, it looks like he’s staying.
The RFU are now hinting at bringing in Martin Johnson as manager and while he has no managerial experience as such, he must have learnt something from his time under Sir Clive Woodward and if he serves as a talisman for the team it might just work. Hopefully!
No Comments »
Posted by: Moose in England, Rugby
Hopefully, within the next hour or so it will be revealed that Brian Ashton has been sacked as England coach. Hopefully, but I doubt it. The problem is that the RFU would have to admit it has made another mistake and that will not happen.
Anyone who is remotely ‘clued-up’ about English rugby will see that the players play a completely different game at club level from when they play under Ashton. The man is probably a decent coach but he is tactically naive at best and technically ignorant at worst. He is not a manager and that is what England had with Clive Woodward and that is what we need now.
If you are unsure about this, simply watch some club rugby and see how good these players are. Although I personally wouldn’t pick the same 15 as Ashton the players he selected were more than good enough to win the grand slam at a canter.
We have a wealth of good coaches in England, the only problem is, we need a manager and the two are very different positions.
No Comments »
Posted by: Moose in England, Rugby
England at last showed some fighting spirit and deserved their victory over France. It does help when we have a front row and they don’t.
Balshaw was again c**p and we must find someone who knows where a full back should be. Still, it is amazing what can happen when you don’t kick away possession all the time.
No Comments »
Posted by: Moose in Rugby
I have been silent for some time on the English rugby embarasment but can hold my tongue no more.
You always know when a coach is in trouble when his supporters feel the need to have more than their fair share of editorial space made available. So who is to blame?
It is quite simple really. Watch the players playing for their club. Do they constantly kick away possession? Do the forwards constantly get in the way of the backs? Do the backs lose their ability to stand steep and pass out to the wing? The answer is obviously no. So why on earth do they do it at International level unless these tactics are coached into them. Why do they play so differently? Again, the answer is obvious.
Brian Ashton is not a good coach and was lucky to get to the world cup final, and it is only this reason that saves him at the moment. It was a disgrace that Wales were allowed to get hold of Shaun Edwards while England overlooked him.
No Comments »